Effectiveness of Balint Groups as Reflective Practice for Nurses in Clinical Settings: A Narrative Review and Reflection on Implementation in a Liaison Mental Health

Derya Nurlu

Abstract

Balint groups are structured reflective practice groups designed to explore the emotional and relational dimensions of clinical encounters. Although widely used in medical training, particularly among psychiatrists and general practitioners, their application within nursing practice has received relatively limited research attention despite nurses’ central role in patient-facing care.

This narrative review examines the effectiveness of Balint groups as reflective practice for nurses working in clinical environments and provides a reflective account of implementing a Balint group within a liaison mental health nursing team in a UK teaching hospital. Literature searches were conducted across PubMed, Google Scholar and ResearchGate using keywords including “Balint group,” “nursing,” and “reflective practice.” A one-year pilot Balint group programme for liaison mental health nurses was also reviewed.

Existing literature suggests that Balint groups may improve empathy, reflective capacity and understanding of clinician–patient relationships. Informal feedback from the pilot group suggested that nurses valued the opportunity to reflect on emotionally challenging encounters and develop alternative perspectives on patient behaviour. Challenges included inconsistent attendance due to shift patterns, concerns regarding confidentiality and difficulty maintaining focus on the nurse–patient relationship.

Balint groups may represent a valuable reflective practice intervention for nurses working in emotionally demanding clinical settings. Further empirical research focusing specifically on nursing populations is required to determine their effectiveness and identify optimal implementation strategies.

Introduction

Reflective practice is widely recognised as an important component of professional development in healthcare. Clinicians frequently encounter emotionally complex situations that require not only technical expertise but also the ability to understand interpersonal dynamics and reflect on their own emotional responses to patients. Within mental health practice, the clinician–patient relationship represents a central component of therapeutic work.

Balint groups represent one of the most established approaches to structured reflective practice in medicine. Developed by psychoanalyst Michael Balint in the 1950s, these groups were originally designed to support general practitioners in understanding the psychological aspects of consultations. Balint introduced the concept of “the doctor as a drug,” highlighting the importance of the clinician’s emotional presence in therapeutic relationships [1].

Over time, Balint groups have become integrated into medical education and psychiatric training programmes internationally. Participation in these groups has been associated with improved empathy, communication skills and clinicians’ capacity for reflective practice [2]. Despite this evidence base, most research examining Balint groups has focused on physicians rather than nurses.

This emphasis overlooks the important role of nurses in patient-facing care. Mental health nurses frequently spend extended periods interacting with patients and often manage emotionally demanding clinical situations. However, structured reflective practice opportunities such as Balint groups are less commonly available within nursing teams.

Liaison mental health nurses working in acute hospital settings encounter particularly complex clinical demands. Their roles often involve rapid psychiatric assessment, risk evaluation and collaboration with multidisciplinary teams while managing high patient volumes and time pressures. These conditions may increase emotional burden and highlight the importance of accessible reflective practice structures.

This article aims to review the effectiveness of Balint groups as reflective practice for nurses and to present a reflective account of implementing a Balint group programme within a liaison mental health nursing team in a UK teaching hospital.

Background

Balint Groups

Balint groups are structured case discussion groups that focus on the relational aspects of clinical encounters rather than clinical management or diagnostic decision-making. Groups typically consist of six to twelve healthcare professionals who meet regularly under the guidance of a trained facilitator.

During sessions, a participant presents a clinical encounter that they experienced as challenging or emotionally significant. The group then reflects on the clinician’s emotional responses and explores the interpersonal dynamics present within the interaction. Through this reflective process, participants may gain insight into both their own reactions and the psychological experiences of patients.

Balint proposed several principles that underpin this approach. First, most clinical encounters contain psychological elements that influence the consultation. Second, clinicians’ emotional responses may provide valuable information about patient experiences. Third, the clinician–patient relationship itself has therapeutic value [1].

Research suggests that Balint groups can enhance clinicians’ ability to reflect on emotional responses and strengthen empathy within patient care [3]. Participation in Balint groups has also been associated with increased professional satisfaction and reduced emotional exhaustion among healthcare professionals [6].

Reflective Practice in Nursing

Reflective practice has long been recognised as an essential element of nursing education and professional development. Nurses frequently encounter emotionally demanding situations involving distress, crisis and interpersonal conflict. Opportunities to reflect on these experiences may therefore support both professional learning and emotional wellbeing.

Mental health nurses often manage complex patient interactions involving behavioural disturbances, trauma histories and psychosocial stressors. The ability to understand relational dynamics and reflect on emotional responses may therefore play a significant role in effective patient care.

However, reflective practice within nursing teams often occurs informally and may focus primarily on clinical decision-making rather than emotional processing. Structured reflective approaches such as Balint groups may therefore provide a valuable framework for exploring the psychological dimensions of clinical work.

Previous studies have suggested that Balint groups may help nurses develop greater insight into therapeutic relationships and enhance their capacity to mentalise patient interactions [5]. Despite these potential benefits, empirical research examining Balint groups specifically within nursing populations remains limited.

Methods

Study Design

We employ a narrative review methodology combined with a reflective account of implementing a Balint group programme within a clinical service. Narrative reviews allow integration of findings from heterogeneous literature and are particularly useful when examining emerging topics where empirical evidence may be limited.

Literature Search

 A literature search was conducted using PubMed, Google Scholar and ResearchGate. Search terms included combinations of “Balint group,” “nursing,” “reflective practice,” “clinical empathy,” and “mentalisation.” Articles examining Balint groups among healthcare professionals were reviewed, with attention given to studies addressing reflective practice and clinician–patient relationships.

Pilot Balint Group Implementation

A pilot Balint group programme was implemented within the Liaison Mental Health Team at Lewisham University Hospital. Weekly one-hour sessions were offered to liaison mental health nurses over a one-year period.

Group sizes ranged from two to six participants, depending on clinical availability and shift patterns. The group was facilitated by a trainee psychiatrist undertaking senior psychiatric training and supervised by a consultant psychiatrist within the service.

Discussion

The findings from this narrative review and pilot implementation suggest that Balint groups may represent a valuable reflective practice intervention for nurses working in emotionally demanding clinical environments. Although most empirical research has focused on physicians, the principles underlying Balint methodology appear highly relevant to nursing practice.

Participants in the pilot group reported that the sessions helped them develop new perspectives on challenging clinical situations. Reflecting collectively on patient interactions allowed clinicians to reconsider the meaning of behaviours that initially appeared confusing or frustrating. This reflective process appears consistent with the concept of mentalisation described in Balint group literature, in which clinicians develop greater awareness of both their own emotional responses and the possible psychological experiences of patients [4].

The opportunity to verbalise emotional reactions also emerged as an important benefit of the group experience. Participants frequently described discussing situations such as managing aggressive behaviour, responding to complaints or coping with patient deaths. In many clinical environments, these experiences may not be openly discussed due to time pressures or organisational culture. Balint groups therefore provide a protected space in which clinicians can articulate emotions that might otherwise remain unaddressed.

Another important observation concerned the development of collegial support among participants. Hearing colleagues describe similar experiences appeared to normalise emotional reactions and reduce feelings of professional isolation. Previous studies have suggested that such peer reflection may contribute to improved job satisfaction and reduced burnout among healthcare professionals [6].

However, the implementation of Balint groups within nursing services presents several practical challenges. Attendance variability was one of the most significant issues observed during the pilot programme. Nursing shift patterns and service demands resulted in fluctuating group membership, which made it difficult to establish stable group dynamics.

Concerns regarding confidentiality also emerged during the early stages of the programme. Some participants initially expressed uncertainty regarding whether discussions might be communicated to management. Establishing trust therefore required clear communication about the purpose of the group and reassurance that sessions were intended solely as reflective practice rather than performance evaluation.

Maintaining the focus of discussion on the nurse–patient relationship also proved challenging. Participants occasionally shifted discussions toward organisational pressures such as workload or interdepartmental conflict. While these issues were clearly relevant to participants’ experiences, they sometimes diverted attention away from the relational exploration central to Balint methodology. Skilled facilitation therefore plays an important role in guiding discussions and maintaining the reflective focus of the group.

Despite these challenges, the pilot programme suggests that nurses generally valued the opportunity to participate in structured reflective discussions. The findings therefore support the potential value of Balint groups as a reflective practice model for nursing teams, particularly within high-intensity clinical settings such as liaison psychiatry.

In future research, we aim to evaluate the impact of Balint groups on measurable outcomes including empathy, burnout and professional satisfaction among nurses. Qualitative work exploring participants’ experiences in greater depth may also provide valuable insights into how Balint groups influence clinical practice and professional wellbeing.

* I am grateful to Professor M. Aamer Sarfraz for his invaluable guidance and support in developing this project, and for his generous contribution to writing

Conclusion

Balint groups provide a structured reflective practice framework that focuses on the emotional and relational aspects of clinical encounters. While widely used within medical education, their potential benefits for nursing staff remain underexplored.

The findings from this narrative review and pilot implementation suggest that Balint groups may support emotional processing, reflective capacity and collegial support among nurses working in demanding clinical environments. However, successful implementation requires attention to practical challenges including attendance consistency, psychological safety and facilitator training.

Further empirical research focusing specifically on nursing populations is required to determine the effectiveness of Balint groups and identify optimal strategies for integrating them into clinical practice.

References

[1] Balint M. The doctor, his patient and the illness. London: Pitman Medical; 1957.

[2] Salinsky J, Sackin P. What are you feeling, doctor? Identifying and avoiding defensive patterns in the consultation. Oxford: Radcliffe Publishing; 2000.

[3] Bing Y, Zhang Y, Li H. Effects of Balint groups on empathy among healthcare professionals. Medical Education. 2024;58(2):145-152.

[4] Farkas B, Csukly G, Fonagy P. Is the Balint group an opportunity to mentalize? International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine. 2023;58(3):203-215.

[5] Green A, Searle E, Hannah L. Using Balint groups in mental health nursing practice. Mental Health Practice. 2017;21(2):19-23.

[6] Kjeldmand D, Holmström I. Balint groups as a means to increase job satisfaction among physicians. Family Practice. 2008;25(2):138-145.

[7] Rabin S, Feldman D. Balint groups and professional development in healthcare. Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions. 2012;32(4):268-273.

[8] Shapiro J, Lie D. Balint groups in medical education. Academic Medicine. 2004;79(3):250-255.

[9] Salinsky J. The Balint movement worldwide: present state and future outlook. American Journal of Psychoanalysis. 2003;63(4):327-335.

[10] Holmes J. Mentalizing and reflective practice in healthcare. Psychiatry. 2010;9(6):231-236.

*Rest of the references are available on request

About the authors

Dr Derya Nurlu is a Higher Psychiatry Resident at Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust